Immortality

QllT · March 2009

This came to me recently as I was thinking about the hidden things in the serries. At the end of book 4 when LV is reborn harry Became Immmortal. This means that in books 5 6 and 7 harry could not actually be killed as long as there Hocruxes out there. Did you guys figure this out before

QllT · July 2009

did anyone see this?

Midnight Spells(Bex) · July 2009

No, I didnt.
It came as a real shock, but it does explain a lot, like how Harry can talk to snakes, etc.

keet · July 2009

No i hadn't figured that out! But thanks for pointing it out!

webkinz · July 2009

Interesting!

ILoveLupin · July 2009

I've never thought of that!
:O

HermioneAnnGranger · July 2009

Oh! Me neither. That explains a lot ... like why he couldn't die when Voldemort tried to kill him in the last part of Deathly Hallows.

Hess · July 2009

In the 7th book harry didn't die and all the horcruxes were destroyed

gryffindorgurl · August 2009

[quote=QllT]This came to me recently as I was thinking about the hidden things in the serries. At the end of book 4 when LV is reborn harry Became Immmortal. This means that in books 5 6 and 7 harry could not actually be killed as long as there Hocruxes out there. Did you guys figure this out before [/quote]

HOW DOES HE BECOME IMMORTAL????? please explain! I just re-read the 4rth book......I do not remember Harry becoming immortal when LV was reborn. How? Why? Sorry for HP my ignorance LOL BUT I DON'T GET IT!

sectumsempra08 · August 2009

hes immortal because he was made into a horcrux the night his parents were killed

gryffindorgurl · August 2009

oooh okay...that does make sense Lol ...........are we supposed to understand this at the end of the 4rth book though? We only learn about the horcruxes in the last book.

gryffindorgurl · August 2009

thanks for the first reply....sorry for the silly questions.....I'm only on my way to becoming an obsessive Harry Potter freak...........I'm sure there is much I do not yet understand =>

sectumsempra08 · August 2009

[quote=gryffindorgurl]are we supposed to understand this at the end of the 4rth book though?[/quote]

i dont think we were supposed to know that in the fourth book because that was only voldemort using harry's blood because it had some of his blood in harry's in order to make him be recreated. i dont think in any way it made harry immortal.

HermioneAnnGranger · August 2009

This is the great thing about Joanne Rowling. She unravvels an amazing story for us throughout the series.

You need to be able to add everything up from the 4th book to the 7th.

gryffindorgurl · August 2009

Ohhh alright, thank you for explaining that! I thought from reading the beggimning of this thread that there was something in the 4rth book that expessidly said that Harry was made immortal, or that he was made immortal sometime during the course of events described in that book. It really bothered me that I didn't find anything like that..lol =>

Wilbo421 · August 2009

Actually Gryffindorgurl, Harry became "immortal" because of what happened on that night in the graveyard, not because of the being a horcrux.

Remember, Wormtail took blood from Harry to rebuild Voldemort's body. That blood becoming Voldemort's meant that Lily's protection was now residing in Voldemort's veins. So when Harry himself was "killed", Lily's remaining protection, ironically now within Voldemort, kept Harry tethered to life. That is why Dumbledore has that momentary flash of triumph in his eyes when Harry tells Dumbledore about Wormtail using Harry's blood in GoF.

The horcrux within Harry was also destroyed however, because of the force of the AK that Voldemort cast.

So there is something in GoF, it was just hidden

Won-Won-x · August 2009

havent we already had a discussion like this??? or am i just bein retarded - anyways, yer it's kind of a given that harry's immortal
'none can live while the other survives' and all dat but i didnt see that - thanks for sharing it :-) one piece of very interesting info that kind of makes me want to finish the book i'm reading for school and start on all the harry books agen hehe :-)

Wilbo421 · August 2009

Where?

GriffindorsFinest! · August 2009

Does this mean Harry cannot be killed?

Wilbo421 · August 2009

[quote=GriffindorsFinest!]
Does this mean Harry cannot be killed? [/quote]

Not till Voldemort himself was dead, no.

hp4gw · September 2009

then Hazza can die of old age - hopefully wid Ginners :-)
NO divorcin please!
hehe xxx

Immortality

Comments