Welcome to Harry Potter Forum! Below you will find many interesting threads and discussions. Enjoy.
Like the Books or the movies better?
Lupin & Kingsley
Posts: 25
I like the books much better.
Lupin & Kingsley
Posts: 25
Lupin & Kingsley
Posts: 25
Comments
COS - Book
POA - Book
GOF - Book
OOTP - Movie
Movies are too short for the seven hundred paged books of Harry Potter.
'CauSe it's MoRe comPlete and It doesn't make me confused
cos - movie
poa - book
gof - book
ootp - movie!
cos - Film
poa - Book
gof - Film
ootp - Film the book is too long:/ but its good anyway;)
the movies are good and i can't wait for hbp but the books are loads beta
COS - Book again more information
POA - Book because it doesn't single out Buckbeak as much and more background.
GOF - BOOK cus they leave dobby out and Winky anddd Ludo Bagman I mean COME ON!
OOTP - Book and film because i mean in the film they miss out ron and hermione being prefects - and they just can't bloody leave that out!! :(
and the book better in someways because the fight it more explained and Sirius's death more emotional.
But the film is better because it describes harry's pain better and how he fought it off although its slightly altered... so probababally over all -
75% Books
25% Movies
Harry Potter and the Chamber Of Secrets - Both, I just wish the film had the Deathday party, and Valentine's day.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner Of Azkaban - The book. To much was cut especially Quidditch.
Harry Potter and the Goblet Of Fire - The book. To much was cut.
Harry Potter and the Order Of the Phoenix - Both, but the film came very close to being better.
From start to finish.
Harry Potter and the Chamber Of Secrets - book, the movie wasn't funny enough unlike the book
Harry Potter and the Prisoner Of Azkaban - the book, there wasn't enough in the movie
Harry Potter and the Goblet Of Fire - the book, there wasn't enough in the movie, especially the visit with sirius
Harry Potter and the Order Of the Phoenix - the book, there wasn't enough in the movie, there should have been more with snape and sirius to show why harry would be so devestated by the death, there wasn't enough to show the bond between the two, in the movie, thought umbridge was great
So if you carry on like it, you're just going to be disappointed by every book adaptation you see that's based on a big book.
but i just know when i see the half blood prince with Dumbledore drinking that potion and saying "KILL ME NOW!" I'll just cry i reckonnn
http://harrypotterkonyv.hu/harry_potter_and_the_halfblood_prince_adult_edition
Sziasztok! Szerintem egy könyv mindig jobb, mint a belőle készült film. A kedvencem a Félvér herceg. Sok érdekességet találtam a fenti oldalon...
COS- movie(I don't know why even though they left put details)
POA- movie
GoF- book
OotP- movie( really liked the ending but could have been extended)
HBP- definetly the book(but movie was still very good)
DH1- I would say both because it was really well made(movie/book)