I am ranking these movies as how satisfied I was with their adaptations...
1. DH part1 2. PoA 3. GoF 4. DH part 2 5. HBP 6. CoS 7. PS 8. OotP
For me, DH part1 and PoA, were perfect and have some very minor complaints for DH part1 than PoA but I still love more DH1
i enjoyed a lot GoF, I only think that the graveyard scene could have been abit better but I still like it. I didnt mind the whole SPEW, Winky to be cut
DH part 2, dont take me wrong, I loved this movie and I cried a lot during my second viewing, I just dont like how my fav chapter of all, The Prince's Tale, was adapted. I mean it is really beautiful, but I would have loved it to have abit more from the book. Also, I think the battle of hogwarts could have been expanded a bit more, and it felt very rushed.
HBP I think the whole Harry and Ginny subplot, the Half-Blood Prince plot ( which is THE TITLE OF THE FILM) could have been adapted better! I do like the whole memories, horcruxes stuff and I didnt really mind that the other memories were cut. I also think that Harry could have told Dumbledore that he didnt trust Snape, but that Dumbledore did, so it had a more emotional impact when Snape killed him... Also, i do miss the funeral, it could have at least lasted 3 mins andbit would have been awesome..
CoS and PS.. i am really grateful with Chris Colombus for casting the trio, the other actors, for establishing the world, for choosing John Williams for the score, etc I love these movies because of that and because of the stories. i just think that the way he filmed all this stuff.. And the editing Its very .. Flat and abrupt.. The scenes doesn't flow like in PoA its just scene cut to another scene cut to another scene, etc
OotP omg... So soo MANY complaints with this one! I'll edit this again to name some of my biggest complaints with this movie
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1 Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
Comments
2: DH1
3: HBP
4: PoA
5: SS
6: GoF
7: OotP
8: CoS
1) DH2
2) DH1
3) HBP
4) OoTP
5) GOF
6) PoA
7) CoS
8) SS
This list is hardly a concrete "list" though. Like, SS is at the bottom, yet it holds greater emotional value for me than any other except DH2.
1. DH part1
2. PoA
3. GoF
4. DH part 2
5. HBP
6. CoS
7. PS
8. OotP
For me, DH part1 and PoA, were perfect and have some very minor complaints for DH part1 than PoA but I still love more DH1
i enjoyed a lot GoF, I only think that the graveyard scene could have been abit better but I still like it. I didnt mind the whole SPEW, Winky to be cut
DH part 2, dont take me wrong, I loved this movie and I cried a lot during my second viewing, I just dont like how my fav chapter of all, The Prince's Tale, was adapted. I mean it is really beautiful, but I would have loved it to have abit more from the book. Also, I think the battle of hogwarts could have been expanded a bit more, and it felt very rushed.
HBP I think the whole Harry and Ginny subplot, the Half-Blood Prince plot ( which is THE TITLE OF THE FILM) could have been adapted better! I do like the whole memories, horcruxes stuff and I didnt really mind that the other memories were cut. I also think that Harry could have told Dumbledore that he didnt trust Snape, but that Dumbledore did, so it had a more emotional impact when Snape killed him... Also, i do miss the funeral, it could have at least lasted 3 mins andbit would have been awesome..
CoS and PS.. i am really grateful with Chris Colombus for casting the trio, the other actors, for establishing the world, for choosing John Williams for the score, etc I love these movies because of that and because of the stories. i just think that the way he filmed all this stuff.. And the editing Its very .. Flat and abrupt.. The scenes doesn't flow like in PoA its just scene cut to another scene cut to another scene, etc
OotP omg... So soo MANY complaints with this one! I'll edit this again to name some of my biggest complaints with this movie
1. Half-Blood Prince
2. Deathly Hallows Part 2
3. Deathly Hallows Part 1
4. Order of the Phoenix
5. Prisoner of Azkaban
6. Chamber of Secrets
7. Philosopher's Stone
8. Goblet of Fire
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire