It's unfair for Shell Cottage, by the way. It's a total of 7 scenes (Harry with the mirror, Bill and Luna, Griphook talk, Trio on stairs, Ollivander talk, Hermione with Bellatrix's hair and Apparating from the Beach), a 10-minute sequence. And there is nothing wrong with this sequence, in fact it's one of the best in the film. Flawless with great acting, quietness, tension and beautiful subtlety.
John, I thought the Shell Cottage was handled really well. But it's the slowest paced sequence of all. Watching the movie for the 4th time made me think: "Ok. I get it. Let's go to Gringotts".
The voting is up, and here are the results for Round 2:
Shell Cottage – 7 Hogsmeade – 7 Bellatrix vs. Molly – 3 Room of Requirement – 2 The Diadem – 1 Neville’s Speech - 1
As you can see, we have a tie for elimination between Shell Cottage and Hogsmeade. Here is the tiebreaker trivia question, whoever answers may choose either Shell Cottage or Hogsmeade to eliminate.
What is the name of the prominent goblin in Gringotts who is killed by dragon fire? What is the name of the actor who plays him?
Scenes Opening Shell Cottage - eliminated Round 2 Inside Gringotts The Vault Dragon Flight Malfoy Manor Massacre Hogsmeade Aberforth The Room of Requirement Snape's Speech Snape vs. McGonagall Voldemort's Ultimatum Ravenclaw Tower Statues The Grey Lady Preparing for Battle Neville on the Bridge In the Chamber of Secrets Voldemort Destroys Protections Covered Bridge Collapses Battle of Hogwarts The Diadem Fiendfyre We Can End This Courtyard Apocalypse Snape's Demise Great Hall Triage The Prince's Tale Staircase Farewell The Resurrection Stone The Forest Again King's Cross Procession Neville's Speech Showdown Bellatrix vs. Molly Voldemort's Death Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1 Viaduct Epilogue
Here is the immunity question for Round 3. What 4 people does Harry hug in the Room of Requirement in Part 2, when they return with Neville? (Order doesn't matter.)
In the Chamber of Secrets has been granted immunity.
Scenes Opening Shell Cottage - eliminated Round 2 Inside Gringotts The Vault Dragon Flight Malfoy Manor Massacre Hogsmeade Aberforth The Room of Requirement Snape's Speech Snape vs. McGonagall Voldemort's Ultimatum Ravenclaw Tower Statues The Grey Lady Preparing for Battle Neville on the Bridge In the Chamber of Secrets - IMMUNITY FOR ROUND 3: Don't vote for it! Voldemort Destroys Protections Covered Bridge Collapses Battle of Hogwarts The Diadem Fiendfyre We Can End This Courtyard Apocalypse Snape's Demise Great Hall Triage The Prince's Tale Staircase Farewell The Resurrection Stone The Forest Again King's Cross Procession Neville's Speech Showdown Bellatrix vs. Molly Voldemort's Death Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1 Viaduct Epilogue
Aaron, what about the scene after Gringotts where the trio change and discuss how they need to go to Hogwarts? Which would that fall under?
Malfoy Manor Massacre begins with the trio falling into the lake and ends with Gryffindor's sword disappearing from Griphook's hands (the shot right before Hogsmeade.)
Aaron, what about the scene after Gringotts where the trio change and discuss how they need to go to Hogwarts? Which would that fall under?
Malfoy Manor Massacre begins with the trio falling into the lake and ends with Gryffindor's sword disappearing from Griphook's hands (the shot right before Hogsmeade.)
Aaaah, okay, I was confused as to whether those would be counted as seperate.
Comments
room of requirement
NOOOO. Don't vote for Hogsmeade! What the hell! Everytime I watch, I get chills when the DE screams "POTTEEEER"
GIFSoup
It's unfair for Shell Cottage, by the way. It's a total of 7 scenes (Harry with the mirror, Bill and Luna, Griphook talk, Trio on stairs, Ollivander talk, Hermione with Bellatrix's hair and Apparating from the Beach), a 10-minute sequence. And there is nothing wrong with this sequence, in fact it's one of the best in the film. Flawless with great acting, quietness, tension and beautiful subtlety.
Wah-wah! Here comes the sun http://www.miedy.com/ (my personal website)
Shell Cottage – 7
Hogsmeade – 7
Bellatrix vs. Molly – 3
Room of Requirement – 2
The Diadem – 1
Neville’s Speech - 1
As you can see, we have a tie for elimination between Shell Cottage and Hogsmeade. Here is the tiebreaker trivia question, whoever answers may choose either Shell Cottage or Hogsmeade to eliminate.
What is the name of the prominent goblin in Gringotts who is killed by dragon fire? What is the name of the actor who plays him?
Opening
Shell Cottage - eliminated Round 2
Inside Gringotts
The Vault
Dragon Flight
Malfoy Manor Massacre
Hogsmeade
Aberforth
The Room of Requirement
Snape's Speech
Snape vs. McGonagall
Voldemort's Ultimatum
Ravenclaw Tower
Statues
The Grey Lady
Preparing for Battle
Neville on the Bridge
In the Chamber of Secrets
Voldemort Destroys Protections
Covered Bridge Collapses
Battle of Hogwarts
The Diadem
Fiendfyre
We Can End This
Courtyard Apocalypse
Snape's Demise
Great Hall Triage
The Prince's Tale
Staircase Farewell
The Resurrection Stone
The Forest Again
King's Cross
Procession
Neville's Speech
Showdown
Bellatrix vs. Molly
Voldemort's Death
Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1
Viaduct
Epilogue
Here is the immunity question for Round 3. What 4 people does Harry hug in the Room of Requirement in Part 2, when they return with Neville? (Order doesn't matter.)
Chamber Of Secrets
Scenes
Opening
Shell Cottage - eliminated Round 2
Inside Gringotts
The Vault
Dragon Flight
Malfoy Manor Massacre
Hogsmeade
Aberforth
The Room of Requirement
Snape's Speech
Snape vs. McGonagall
Voldemort's Ultimatum
Ravenclaw Tower
Statues
The Grey Lady
Preparing for Battle
Neville on the Bridge
In the Chamber of Secrets - IMMUNITY FOR ROUND 3: Don't vote for it!
Voldemort Destroys Protections
Covered Bridge Collapses
Battle of Hogwarts
The Diadem
Fiendfyre
We Can End This
Courtyard Apocalypse
Snape's Demise
Great Hall Triage
The Prince's Tale
Staircase Farewell
The Resurrection Stone
The Forest Again
King's Cross
Procession
Neville's Speech
Showdown
Bellatrix vs. Molly
Voldemort's Death
Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1
Viaduct
Epilogue
Round 3 commences now.
Aaron, what about the scene after Gringotts where the trio change and discuss how they need to go to Hogwarts? Which would that fall under?
GIFSoup
Wah-wah! Here comes the sun http://www.miedy.com/ (my personal website)