Welcome to Harry Potter Forum! Below you will find many interesting threads and discussions. Enjoy.
The Official DH2 Scene Survivor Game! (The Prince's Tale WINS!)
To spice up the mood here, I've decided to start a little game of my own--welcome to Deathly Hallows: Part 2 Scene Survivor. This game is exactly like the Part 2 Soundtrack Survivor but with scenes rather than tracks. Let's begin!
Rules (Credit to Pensieve Seeker)
-Voting will commence for round 1 on July 25 at 1am P.S.T. and conclude on July 26 at 5pm P.S.T. Votes submitted prior to the start or after the deadline will not be counted.
-Starting with Round 2, each round will have an immunity question at the start of each round. The person answering the question must state which track they would like to receive immunity for that round. Voting then begins only when I state that the correct answer has been given, along with immunity. The track receiving immunity cannot be voted for in that particular round.
-In the event of a tie, the track which has received the most votes in the previous round(s) will be eliminated. If there is still a tie after that, then a tie-breaking question will be asked.
-When voting, please use the exact scene titles as listed here rather than being vague, as you might be in the line between two scenes.
Scenes
Opening - eliminated Round 16
Shell Cottage - eliminated Round 2
Inside Gringotts - eliminated Round 15
The Vault - eliminated Round 13
Dragon Flight - eliminated Round 29
Malfoy Manor Massacre - eliminated Round 14
Hogsmeade - eliminated Round 3
Aberforth - eliminated Round 6
The Room of Requirement - eliminated Round 7
Snape's Speech - eliminated Round 19
Snape vs. McGonagall - eliminated Round 24
Voldemort's Ultimatum - eliminated Round 17
Ravenclaw Tower - eliminated Round 5
Statues - eliminated Round 37
The Grey Lady - eliminated Round 11
Preparing for Battle - eliminated Round 28
Neville on the Bridge - eliminated Round 9
In the Chamber of Secrets - eliminated Round 18
Voldemort Destroys Protections - eliminated Round 22
Covered Bridge Collapses - eliminated Round 12
Battle of Hogwarts - eliminated Round 34
The Diadem - eliminated Round 4
Fiendfyre - eliminated Round 25
We Can End This - eliminated Round 8
Courtyard Apocalypse - eliminated Round 39
Snape's Demise - eliminated Round 36
Great Hall Triage - eliminated Round 23
The Prince's Tale - WINNER!!!!!!!
Staircase Farewell - eliminated Round 31
The Resurrection Stone - eliminated Round 38
The Forest Again - eliminated Round 26
King's Cross - eliminated Round 20
Procession - eliminated Round 30
Neville's Speech - eliminated Round 21
Showdown - eliminated Round 33
Bellatrix vs. Molly - eliminated Round 10
Voldemort's Death - eliminated Round 35
Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1
Viaduct - eliminated Round 27
Epilogue - eliminated Round 32
Round 1 commences now. State your least favorite scene from Part 2 (use the list.)
Rules (Credit to Pensieve Seeker)
-Voting will commence for round 1 on July 25 at 1am P.S.T. and conclude on July 26 at 5pm P.S.T. Votes submitted prior to the start or after the deadline will not be counted.
-Starting with Round 2, each round will have an immunity question at the start of each round. The person answering the question must state which track they would like to receive immunity for that round. Voting then begins only when I state that the correct answer has been given, along with immunity. The track receiving immunity cannot be voted for in that particular round.
-In the event of a tie, the track which has received the most votes in the previous round(s) will be eliminated. If there is still a tie after that, then a tie-breaking question will be asked.
-When voting, please use the exact scene titles as listed here rather than being vague, as you might be in the line between two scenes.
Scenes
Opening - eliminated Round 16
Shell Cottage - eliminated Round 2
Inside Gringotts - eliminated Round 15
The Vault - eliminated Round 13
Dragon Flight - eliminated Round 29
Malfoy Manor Massacre - eliminated Round 14
Hogsmeade - eliminated Round 3
Aberforth - eliminated Round 6
The Room of Requirement - eliminated Round 7
Snape's Speech - eliminated Round 19
Snape vs. McGonagall - eliminated Round 24
Voldemort's Ultimatum - eliminated Round 17
Ravenclaw Tower - eliminated Round 5
Statues - eliminated Round 37
The Grey Lady - eliminated Round 11
Preparing for Battle - eliminated Round 28
Neville on the Bridge - eliminated Round 9
In the Chamber of Secrets - eliminated Round 18
Voldemort Destroys Protections - eliminated Round 22
Covered Bridge Collapses - eliminated Round 12
Battle of Hogwarts - eliminated Round 34
The Diadem - eliminated Round 4
Fiendfyre - eliminated Round 25
We Can End This - eliminated Round 8
Courtyard Apocalypse - eliminated Round 39
Snape's Demise - eliminated Round 36
Great Hall Triage - eliminated Round 23
The Prince's Tale - WINNER!!!!!!!
Staircase Farewell - eliminated Round 31
The Resurrection Stone - eliminated Round 38
The Forest Again - eliminated Round 26
King's Cross - eliminated Round 20
Procession - eliminated Round 30
Neville's Speech - eliminated Round 21
Showdown - eliminated Round 33
Bellatrix vs. Molly - eliminated Round 10
Voldemort's Death - eliminated Round 35
Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1
Viaduct - eliminated Round 27
Epilogue - eliminated Round 32
Round 1 commences now. State your least favorite scene from Part 2 (use the list.)
Post edited by aaron on
Comments
Great Hall Aftermath
BTW, here are some elaborations--
Ravenclaw Tower--Harry leaving the Hall, talking to Ron/Hermione about Horcruxes, running up the stairs with Luna following, they talk on the staircase and watch protections.
Statues--McGonagall talks to Neville/Seamus, summons the statues, she and Flitwick, Slughorn, and Molly set up protections, knights go out on the bridge.
The Grey Lady--this scene is split into two parts, just imagine it as one, their entire conversation. It is kind of interspersed with other scenes.
Preparing for Battle--Remus and Tonks on the tower, Fred and George on the tower, knights watching as protections crumble, Remus and Kingsley with Dean on the battlements, Voldemort on the hill. Death Eaters send spells flying into the shield.
Um I was deciding between the covered bridge or the great hall aftermath, and it hurts me to do this so much because I actually do like it, but my vote goes to:
Great Hall Aftermath.
Great Hall Aftermath
'Hogsmeade'
'The Room of Requirement'
'Ravenclaw Tower'
'Neville on the Bridge'
'Bellatrix vs. Molly'
'Great Hall Aftermath'
'Hogsmeade' is good, but too quick and the cat scream alarm was weird, in my opinion. :P
The Room of Requirement was a bit awkward in some little moments. Also, Luna's sudden appearance creates a bit of a plothole.
'Ravenclaw Tower' was a bit indifferent, because it's a 2-minute sequence with not anything important happening.
'Neville on the Bridge' is very cool, but it's not a favorite scene of mine.
'Bellatrix vs. Molly' is well-shot, but it happens so randomly in the middle of the big showdown and there was no other battling in the Great Hall which disappointed me severely.
'Great Hall Aftermath' was short and sweet, but the lack of some proper reaction from the survivors to Voldemort's death made it feel a bit random and rushed.
Though, the scene that I find to be the weakest is the Grand Staircases Panic/Battle sequence, where Harry finds Ginny and Neville and Neville has the whatever line about Luna. It's the only moment where I cringed in the film and it felt forced, awkward and badly-written. I guess this is in the 'Battle of Hogwarts' scene which, except for this moment, is a pretty amazing scene, so I don't know.
Hm, I'll vote for the 'Great Hall Aftermath', I guess. It's a lovely little scene, yeah, but it's too short and lacks pathos and emotion, especially after the killing of Voldemort which was...pretty much a big deal, you know.
GIFSoup
in the chamber of secrets my fav scene
unforgetable =(( =(( i've lost ron 4 eva
Great Hall Aftermath – 8
Shell Cottage – 4
Bellatrix vs. Molly – 1
The Grey Lady – 1
Epilogue – 1
Room of Requirement – 1
Hogsmeade – 1
Procession – 1
With 8 votes, Great Hall Aftermath is eliminated.
Scenes
Opening
Shell Cottage
Inside Gringotts
The Vault
Dragon Flight
Malfoy Manor Massacre
Hogsmeade
Aberforth
The Room of Requirement
Snape's Speech
Snape vs. McGonagall
Voldemort's Ultimatum
Ravenclaw Tower
Statues
The Grey Lady
Preparing for Battle
Neville on the Bridge
In the Chamber of Secrets
Voldemort Destroys Protections
Covered Bridge Collapses
Battle of Hogwarts
The Diadem
Fiendfyre
We Can End This
Courtyard Apocalypse
Snape's Demise
Great Hall Triage
The Prince's Tale
Staircase Farewell
The Resurrection Stone
The Forest Again
King's Cross
Procession
Neville's Speech
Showdown
Bellatrix vs. Molly
Voldemort's Death
Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1
Viaduct
Epilogue
Here is the immunity question for Round 2:
In the epilogue of Part 2, name the full names of Harry and Ginny's children in the order that we see them on screen.
I didn't want Epilogue to get eliminated.
Epilogue.
Epilogue.
Scenes
Opening
Shell Cottage
Inside Gringotts
The Vault
Dragon Flight
Malfoy Manor Massacre
Hogsmeade
Aberforth
The Room of Requirement
Snape's Speech
Snape vs. McGonagall
Voldemort's Ultimatum
Ravenclaw Tower
Statues
The Grey Lady
Preparing for Battle
Neville on the Bridge
In the Chamber of Secrets
Voldemort Destroys Protections
Covered Bridge Collapses
Battle of Hogwarts
The Diadem
Fiendfyre
We Can End This
Courtyard Apocalypse
Snape's Demise
Great Hall Triage
The Prince's Tale
Staircase Farewell
The Resurrection Stone
The Forest Again
King's Cross
Procession
Neville's Speech
Showdown
Bellatrix vs. Molly
Voldemort's Death
Great Hall Aftermath - eliminated Round 1
Viaduct
Epilogue - IMMUNITY FOR ROUND 2: DON'T VOTE FOR IT!
Round 2 commences now.