How will Harry know Ginny, Neville and Luna tried stealing the sword

halfbloodprincefilm · June 2010

Do you think the filmmakers will make Harry know about that like in the book? I had this idea how it will adapted in the movie: Remember the first sneak peak where there's a scene in tent where is Harry opening the Marauder's Map. I think harry will look at the map because he misses Hogwarts and Ginny. He will then scan the map then see the dots of Ginny, Luna and Neville in Dumbledore's Office. The camera will zoom in the map and we'll see the actual Ginny, Luna and Neville trying to steal it then Snape will catch them. Then the camera will zoom out from the map with Harry looking mad at the dot of Snape.

What do you think?

Here is the scene I been talking about:

[Deleted User] · June 2010

we were working on another theory that dobby wil repalce phineas and reminder we dont have proof hes been cut but that could work too

halfbloodprincefilm · June 2010

yeah I think using Dobby is another good theory.

Macedonian · June 2010

this is not in the Grimmauld Place you clearly see the radio on the right side and the mirror of siruis this is in the tent.

halfbloodprincefilm · June 2010

ah ok. yeah i'm starting to realize that this is the tent. i'll modify my post. tnx Macedonian

decarus · June 2010

That is a good idea though halfblood. I don't know if they are going to show Ginny, Luna, and Neville trying to steal the sword only because the actors that play Luna and Neville said they were only in a scene on the train in Part 1. They may have misspoke though because i am pretty sure that Luna is at the wedding. I don't know. I wouldn't mind them showing the scene where they steal the sword, i am just not sure how that would work.

Richard · June 2010

It would be great if they show them stealing it but i doubt it....

Braveheart · June 2010

It would be great to show them stealing it. It would mean more Snape. That was a big complaint of mine about the last book; the complete lack of Snape. I'm glad they seem to have added his speech at the opening feast, but for some reason I just can't see them showing them trying to steal the sword, which I think is a shame. The first rule of cinema is show and not tell. I'm afraid that I think we'll be having a lot of the latter in these films, from the interviews we've had so far.

Richard · June 2010

True braveheart,i cant see them putting that scene on there,but it should be there....At least a deleted scene right?!?

aaron · June 2010

Can you actually imagine Snape up there giving a speech? What would he say?

Braveheart · June 2010

I've had trouble imagining what he would say too, without it sounding horribly stilted. But apparently they have so...

decarus · June 2010

Well he may introduce the Carrows and talk about Dumbledore's death. It is strange to think about what he will say.

halfbloodprincefilm · June 2010

I hope they'll show it. I agree with decarus I think Snape will introduce the carrows as new faculty members. I think Alan Rickman will pull off that speech brilliantly

Richard · June 2010

OMG i so want him to talk bout Dumbledore! I want him to say he didnt kill him and HP is a liar and talk bad bout him!!!!! Sweet!!!

halfbloodprincefilm · June 2010

yeah richard. I also think brainwashing the Hogwarts students is a good theme for Snape's speech

Pensieve Seeker · June 2010

[quote=aaron]Can you actually imagine Snape up there giving a speech? What would he say? [/quote]
Well, prior to his speech I think he'd say something like "Quiet! Your attention, please! Quiet! Hey! Don't make me flick the lights on and off!"

Richard · June 2010

Lol pensieve seeker!!!

How will Harry know Ginny, Neville and Luna tried stealing the sword

Comments