Is dumbledore actully dead?

postopia123 · September 2009

well as you can see, dumbledore "died" in the sixth book. but doesnt his soul march on? and we all know how voldemort got destroyed, or do we?

keet · September 2009

Well in the book nearly headless nick said you can choose to be a ghost.... or not, and Dumbledore chose to not be a ghost, although he does still have the portrait in his office!

hp4gw · September 2009

erm he's dead. otherwise i think Harry wud know about it, dont you?

lupinshowl · October 2009

ok..............so Dumbledore is a portrait now in Snape's office (aka Dumbledore's old office).................wtf?................why not just have Snape go and get Potter and have him sit one on one with Dumbledore's picture and Dumbledore can help Harry out that way, even though he is dead at least he can guide Harry in the right direction....................Dumbledore can be a real a$$ cow................he left everything to chance...............I like Dumbledore but at the same time...................I gotta be pissed at him about that................

Snape could still have protected Harry.....................He could've hidden Harry within Hogwarts..............Voldemort would not know.................cause Snape is a master of occlumency................

keet · October 2009

Dumbledore knew Harry had to do it by myself, he guided him in the right direction, just didn't tell him excactly where to go

Jo · October 2009

Yes, Dumbledor is dead! He died... but that doesn´t mean he's gone, does it? In the seventh book he talks to Harry in some kind of "Twilight Zone", named Kings Kross

lupinshowl · October 2009

.................Dumbledore's not dead............he went with Rumbleroar to Pigfarts.............its in A Very Potter Musical............check out the musical on youtube................it was great.............

...........well when Dumbledore talks to Harry at Kings Kross............Harry was dead for a moment.............he had an outer body experience........Harry had to die so that the part of Voldemort inside Harry would die...............and according to Dumbledore (when he tells Snape in Snapes memory that Harry sees in the pensieve)................Voldemort must kill Harry............Harry must die..........Snape didn't understand.........but Dumbledore knew what must happen.......So at Kings Kross...............that was Dumbledore's soul or spirit.......whatever you wanna call it............

keet · October 2009

^^ well said!

lupinshowl · October 2009

thank you keet.....................and you thought I knew nothing of Harry Potter...................how you doing with your swine flu?...............hope all is good.................I need you here..............I mean we, we need you here............(wink-wink)............

keet · October 2009

Er thanx.... lol...
I'm still dying slowly and painfully

lupinshowl · October 2009

............awwww.........well I hope the best for you.................be sure to drink gatorade as you would need the electrolytes..................and keep hydrated too..................plenty of rest..................one of my best friends had it a few weeks back.....................I went to see her and she told me that..............plus she had alot of different prescriptions.............and one was a temporary steroid she had to take..............she told me that the swine flu left some type of scarring on her lungs................she just found out this week from her doctor..............I was really scared for her when she was sick.................hope you get better.....................

keet · October 2009

^lol!!! thanks for your pesimistic words lupinshowl~!

Is dumbledore actully dead?

Comments