I guess neville/luna IS confirmed

Festax0333

" The film refers to a non-canon relationship between Neville and Luna, which feels unnatural"

from hypable

lol

Richard

YAY!

Nick

:-))

CoolestGuyOnHPF

btw who did neville end up with in the book? forgot :P

Mac

The Hell?

Festax0333

btw who did neville end up with in the book? forgot :P

well he married hannah abott

but he and luna mightve dated, who knows

blackvenom

Cool! I was surprised they didn't end up together in the book.

XDMorsmordreXD

Kiss! Kiss already!

No; that'd be horrible.
H.P isn't a romance tale.

Lord_Darkeyes

OMG! Yes!

Festax0333

they wont kiss lol

but that stare is nice

Richard

fuck yes

Ash

lmao

Festax0333

i like neville/luna cause i feel neville used to be kind tense, nervous and luna was the one who could calm him down, relax him

idk i liked them in ootp

"well done neville"
and him pulling her out of harms way

CoolestGuyOnHPF

Kiss! Kiss already!

No; that'd be horrible.
H.P isn't a romance tale.

Doesnt mean its not funny to find out who everyone end up with?

Ash

Festax0333

lmao

Richard

)

XDMorsmordreXD

me?

Lord_Darkeyes

LOLOLOL

Jackardy

Kiss! Kiss already!

No; that'd be horrible.
H.P isn't a romance tale.

you obviously havent watched Half Blood Prince recently :-D

XDMorsmordreXD

Kiss! Kiss already!

No; that'd be horrible.
H.P isn't a romance tale.

you obviously havent watched Half Blood Prince recently :-D

Nah-I've read it loads :-D

Richard

bull

mattStrelow

I hated this, seriously.

Luna deserves to be portrayed as an odd person, excentric. Love is too cliché for Luna

CoolestGuyOnHPF

mayby its wierd love, lol

blackvenom

Neville says the line and they sit together at the end. They don't show anything more. :P

Hinkypunk

Well, that's fine ! Neville deserves some lovin' !! :X This will be a sweet moment for them both so why not !

mattStrelow

Why didn't they just cast Hannah Abbott back and have Neville say he's crazy about her?

Hinkypunk

Why didn't they just cast Hannah Abbott back and have Neville say he's crazy about her?

Because we've never ever been introduced to Hannah Abbott in the films. Not until the deleted scene in CoS was worked back into it. Everyone would be like.....Who ?

CoolestGuyOnHPF

mayby they wanted him to end up with someone more ''known'' in the series

Nick

HMMM ill bet he says this kissing luna thing right after his i feel like i could spit fire line?

CoolestGuyOnHPF

HMMM ill bet he says this kissing luna thing right after his i feel like i could spit fire line?

hah that would be so beast!

Nick

yea the more i think about it the more i like it and ill admit when i first heard this i was completely hating it but yea it sounds cool

mattStrelow

Why didn't they just cast Hannah Abbott back and have Neville say he's crazy about her?

Because we've never ever been introduced to Hannah Abbott in the films. Not until the deleted scene in CoS was worked back into it. Everyone would be like.....Who ?

Yeah, we weren't actually introduced to her, but she's credited in PoA and GoF, I remember she's one of those Hufflepuffs with Cedric buttons that mock Harry at the Transfiguration Courtyard

decarus

This is a little weird, but whatever. It never says who they end up with anyways so if they want to make something up then go for it i guess.

Festax0333

its not like itl be a big subplot, just the line and then the ending

im fine with it, i even like it

decarus

Well as i have said i hate it when JKR comments so i don't care what she said.

MadBella

i always saw neville and luna together anyway....wooooo

decarus

I would rather she didn't give the information. As far as i am concerned her commenting on the books after the fight has all, but ruined the story by changing what we know and has certainly ruined all future discussion about the characters. I hate it.

It isn't canon and i try and not hear it, but people bring it up all the time like it is canon.

decarus

Yeah i don't actually know the answers to any of those questions you asked and i would rather keep it that way. Speculation is a lot more fun to me. And canon is what is in the text of the books. Nothing she says is canon at all. She has made me find the story less interesting because of some of the stuff she has said afterwords. Also who really cares who ends up with who when it isn't important to the story. Why would she ever answer a question like that. I just don't get it. All it does is pull me out of the story in a way i don't like.

We can, of course, agree to disagree.

Lord_Darkeyes

this confirms Luna/Neville:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1201607/parentalguide

decarus

I know that people really like her comments. And i try not to go into this very often. But i really cannot explain the depths of my hate of her comments. It makes me absolutely crazy so i just try to not think of it. I certainly don't read them if i can help it.

Riku

Luna/Neville is amazing. Jo should just retcon the Hannah Abbot thing
but seriously, it's not against what Jo said. Maybe they dated. Maybe Luna turned him down-- Ohhhhh, ouch.

Nick

hate to be the bearer of bad news but a member on COS forums says he has seen the movie and he dosent remember neville mentioning luna at all so i dont know what to think :-?

RyGuy

Iomg idk whata too thsibk about This all. Lije omg

HPfangirl4life

i feel like test screeners would of definitely mentioned this wouldn't they

Nick

well hypable mentioned it and thats run by mugglenet and they mentioned it. Chace a member of Hpf saw an advanced screening and he says he dosent remember seeing this in the film. now we have a COS Forums person who has seen the film saying NO this never happened. i really wish someone would just give us a straight answer

chester

I always thought Luna and Neville would end up together.

fortuna_maior

As far as I know, Neville marries Hannah Abbot who becomes the owner of the Leaky Cauldron and Neville himself works first for the Ministry of Magic before becoming teacher for Herbology at Hogwarts.
As for Luna, she becomes a natural scientist and later marries Rolf Scamander, who is the grandchild of Newt Scamander (author of "Phantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them").

decarus

None of that happens in the book.

Lord Stafford

None of that happens in the book.

It is still canon, this isn't.

Lord Stafford.

decarus

No it isn't canon. And this is film canon. More canon then the nonsense JKR says.