The Harry Potter "What If" Game

HuffleBen

Helloo everyone!
everything has been quite serious recently, what with the trailer talk etc
so i introduce to you the...
WHAT IF GAME!!
the concept is...somebody (i.e Me) will say what if..(Voldemort never returned)
the person who comments next has to answer the question, then ask another
so for example..

Me:What if Harry and Ron never met?
Richard: It would be rubbish
What if Hermione was a lesbian (haha)


Cool
Have fun guys!

Festax0333

what if dudley was a wizard?

HuffleBen

The wizarding world would be a much dumber place...

What if Dumbledore didn't die

Richard

Dumbledore wouldve kicked Voldys ass again.

What if Harry was not a wizard?

Nick

if harry wasnt a wizard then the series wouldnt exist

HuffleBen

you're supposed to do another what if...?
ok then
What if Hagrid Died in the Battle Over Little Whinging?

Nick

what if Bellatrix Had A daughter

HuffleBen

There would be one epic Ginny/Bellatrix JR Fight!!
what if harry was sorted into slytherin?

Richard

Hed be EVIL

what if hermione loved harry?

GodricGryffindor

Ron and Harry would be enemies.
WHAT IF SCORPIOUS MALFOY AND ROSE WEASLEY
ENDED UP MARRIED?!


G.G.

Richard

the malfoys and potters would be closer.

What if voldy loved bellatrix?

Nick

there would be a dark lord heir

what if voldermort had not died at the end oh dh and just went to azkaban?

HuffleBen

Voldy Can't Love-But if he did, the whole story could change...

what if Neville was the chosen one?

Richard

Nick: There would be more sequels

Ben: It would be called Neville Longbottom instead

What if Dumbledore died in COS?

gpm

Then Harry would have grown up with his parents.

What if Slughorn had never given harry his memory?

Richard

Dumbeldore wouldve forced it out of slughorn.

What if voldy didnt have horcruxes?

XDMorsmordreXD

Dumbledore would have to tell Harry about horcruxes anyway. The only reason why Dumbledore needed the memory was to make sure his theory was right.

What if Harry really died?

gpm

Then he would have died when Lily sacrificed herself to save Harry.

If Hedwig survived 7 potters then would she have traveled with the trio.

Richard

if harry really died voldy would rule forever.

what if voldy didnt have horcuxes? what if dumbledore was evil?

Richard

yes GPM

what if dumbledore was evil?

gpm

To richards question.Then he would have died when Lily sacrificed herself to save Harry.

gpm

Then he would have betrayed harry only to be stopped by all the friends that surrounded him at hogwarts.

XDMorsmordreXD

If Voldy didn't have Horcruxes then I don't think the series would exist. If Dumbledore was evil then...well...he'd be training young wizards to be dark wizards.

What if Voldemort never used Harry in his re-birth?

gpm

What if Richard was an extra in DH2?

XDMorsmordreXD

What if Richard was an extra in DH2?

Then the entire movie would have been spoiled and July 15th wouldn't be fun...

Wolf_Potter

He would be a Death Eater!

What If Dumbledore was GAY? . . . wait. he's gay
JK
What If Dumbledore and Grindelwald never met?

Richard

lol no i wouldnt spoil everything XD

then dumbeldore wouldve loved mcgonagall

what if harry used the AK curse to kill voldy?

Ash

then dumbeldore wouldve loved mcgonagall

:-))

gpm

Then his soul would be split and he will have lost his innocence.

Wolf_Potter

The game is over?

Richard

What if snape never gave HP his memories?

Wolf_Potter

EDIT:

What if snape never gave HP his memories?

We all would've think (and Harry) that Snape was loyal to Voldemort.

Richard

What if Hermione was a boy?

XDMorsmordreXD

If Princes Tale didn't exist then I think Snapes death wouldn't have been as sad. When I first read that Snape died so drastically, I was shocked but wasn't actually in tears. But after the emotional chapter that was Princes Tale, I was like ' Oh Crap', he was good.

Festax0333

if hermione was a boy the movies would lose sex appeal (:

wat if harry dated luna?

aaron

He would've found nargles in his pants.

What if Dumbledore was straight?

Alfiewits

Then he would of been a pimp with all of the teachers

What if nearly headless nick was actually headless?

XDMorsmordreXD

Then dinner would be disturbing.

What if Snape was Filch's character and Filch was Snape's character?

aaron

Then Lily needs to pick her friends better.

What if Harry didn't have glasses?

Alfiewits

Then ur profile pic wudnt make sense

What if James potter had a horcrux?

dobby_freak19

harry would have grow up with his parents because he would have returned XD
What if dolores umbridge had married severus snape?

Kranen

Snape still would have been good.
What if James & Lily never had sex...

Richard

There would be no Harry

What if I wasnt on HPF?

Kranen

We would all be lost, lonely souls.

What if JK Rowling died before she started writing DH?

Richard

Then someone wouldve continued OR it wouldve ended there.

What if there was no WWOHP?

aaron

Then we would never know what actual butterbeer tasted like.

What if Yates was never hired to direct the last films?

Richard

Then someone else wouldve directed it.

What if cuaron made all the films?

dobby_freak19

there would have never be character development at all

what if sirius had actually betrayed lily and james?

Richard

Then harry would hate sirius

what if cuaron made all the hp fi,lms?

Kranen

Then harry would hate sirius

what if cuaron made all the hp fi,lms?

Than I would kill myself. I hated PoA.

What if just anyone could join HPF?

Richard

Then there would be trolls everyday.

What if snape lived?