Do you think we´ll see the Potter´s death scene in DH2 ?

seamus

After Part I? Because if you could notice, in the scene when Harry´s looking at their house, there is the Philosopher´s Stone flashback and also a new shot of dead Lily on the floor..so unfortunately, I think that´s all ..

aaron

So many threads have been made about this. I hope so. I even made a screenplay for the opening, its in one of the other threads LOL.

Lord Stafford

It can only start that way (for it to be right) but i doubt it because it just doesn't seem to be something that Yates would do, even if it is right (which it is) and it's very likely to be unfortunate and incredibly disappointing in that case though it will still hopefully be a good opening at Shell Cottage!

Lord Stafford.

Bane

No.

Lord Stafford

Very elaborate of you darth. lol!

Lord Stafford.

superpotterfan

I dont think so, I was glad we didnt saw the whole flashback, just the 2 second scenes of it, we already know they were killed blahblah

Bane

Well, I've explained my points on that in other topics. I would rather just go thinking that it won't be there, so I'm not disappointed if I hold out on the hope that it is.

Lord Stafford

Ah, super... but we haven't seen James' death and/or Voldy's downfall, have we?

Lord Stafford.

Nick

i dont think it will open with the potters death

superpotterfan

well yeah, it would have been cool to see it, but I didnt mind, I think it was ok without it

silverarrowgriffin

i want it in part 2

Lord Stafford

It made the scene not good enough. That is simple!

Lord Stafford.

Lord Stafford

So do i, but i still highly doubt it unfortunately!

Lord Stafford.

Hess

Actually we dont know what to expect about the beginning, considering Part 1's, wich was so good and original.

Lord Stafford

Part 2 is a totally different animal though!

Lord Stafford.

TheDoctor

I really really hope so. They're selling James's wand, and we got that new shot of Lily dead. I wonder if they filmed it for Part 1, didn't like it because the film already had lots of flashbacks, so they moved it to Part 2. Also I think the audience needs to be reminded of what happened that night since it becomes so relevant later on in the film.

I am trying not to get my hopes up though. =/

Phoenix007

I really hope they do,it was one of my favourrite parts in the book but they might not seeing as their was one in Philosopher's stone,but without James and Ralph Fiennes

decarus

I don't think they will start with it, but it could possibly be in there. I think they will start with the trio at Shell Cottage or them talking to Ollivander and Griphook.

Lord Stafford

It has to be in there somewhere!

Lord Stafford.

Nick

UH there was a flash of the death in the movie

jonny7003

I doubt it. I think those quick flashes of dead Lily and Voldemort outside the destroyed Potter house in Part 1 replaces the full scene.

Lord Stafford

Well that is pathetic then, Jonny, and yes i know that Nick!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

We need to see it fully.

Lord Stafford

Definetely Rich!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

But i doubt it stafford,yates tends to give "shots" of things like not full scenes. Ill be surprised if its fully shown.

Lord Stafford

Yeah, it probs won't be shown in its entirety (as Yates isn't someone to care about that kind of moment)... which is a terrible shame as it is without a shadow of a doubt in my mind and other true fans alongside me, the most historical and important part in the complete HP franchise. Because without it, we simply wouldn't be here otherwise would we?!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

Not at all. Any and every director who cares truly i mean TRULY would have the scene in full.

Lord Stafford

Yeah, that is why i already have a dream... once i hopefully eventually achieve my goal of becoming a director, i will put myself fully and TRULY forward for a remake of the HP series... and do it right!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

Stafford ill support you

Lord Stafford

I'm not even joking as well!

Lord Stafford.

silverarrowgriffin

Harry could have it as some sort of a dream in a random scene or when he gets in Voldemort's head

Lord Stafford

Yes, griffin... that would do, but it has to be complete (and hopefully at the beginning, that would be perfect) and it has to be there, in the first place!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

I hate those visions,theyre never complete. It has to be a flashback not vision.

silverarrowgriffin

i remember someone posting something about making the potter's death as the intro for part 2?

Richard

Hopefully.

silverarrowgriffin

I hope it'll really be the intro...Everyone should know what exactly happened on that night

Richard

Yes thats the whole point of everything!!

Lord Stafford

Precisely griffin! most of my family and some friends don't have a clue about what happened that terrible night, at all... and it is about time the filmakers redeem themselves and give us what we all really want to see! isn't it?

Lord Stafford.

Richard

Yes! If we dont see it it wont be a perfect finale.

Lord Stafford

And... alot of people will not understand, plus the finale won't make sense without it, because we'll all wonder why we never saw James' death and the most heartbreaking scene ever in the franchise, that it sure as hell was!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

Its the obvious thing to show the potters death. It would be great if it opens!!

silverarrowgriffin

I was actually saying "Oh my God this is it" when they were in Godric's Hollow then I got massively disappointed. It's so annoying. It wouldn't hurt to add a minute or so in the movie for that scene.

Richard

Well if they saved it for part 2 id be happy.

silverarrowgriffin

Well if they saved it for part 2 id be happy.

and part 2 would be totally worth waiting for

Lord Stafford

Very much so, but once again... this is something that they seem unable to understand in us real fans, so it is highly unlikely. I must admit, unfortunately!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

*sigh*

Lord Stafford

That is all we can do... sigh, we have no say unfortunately, so it won't be the best it could be, i just wish they would have some sense and realise now, how important it is to us and the vital overall plot, it simply would be complete without it!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

And ppl should witniss voldys downfall!!

Lord Stafford

Exactly, we need it!

Lord Stafford.

Richard

But mike said theres no ppl.

Lord Stafford

What?

Lord Stafford.