The Best of the HP movies:

thisishogwarts

What I mean:

Best movie overall: HBP
Best Music: John Williams for PoA
Best Directing: Alfonso Cuaron for PoA
Best Editing: PoA
Best Cinematography: HBP
Best Story: PoA
Best Acting (younger cast): Daniel Radcliffe in Half Blood Prince
Best Acting (adult cast): Gary Oldman for PoA
Best Comedy: GoF
Best Pacing: HBP
Best Song from entire series: Window to the Past, PoA
Best Opening: HBP
Best Ending: HBP
Best Set Design: HBP/PoA/GoF
Best Harry: HBP
Best Ron: GoF
Best Hermione: HBP or CoS
Best Ending Credits: GoF
Most Epic Moment: The Journey to the cave in HBP
Best Hair Style: PoA - joke one :)
Darkest Movie: OoTP or GoF
Best Trailer: DH
Worst overall Movie: CoS
Best Visuals: HBP
Best Special Effects: HBP
Best Quidditch Game: HBP

Feel free to add anymore categories.

Richard

Best adult actor is alanrickman.........Best hermione is poa......best end credits is poa......best movie poa......best ron is ootp......i practically agree with everything else^^
R:,)

aaron

I'd say change Ending Credits to POA and Best Comedy to HBP

Darkest Movie: GOF (probably soon to be DH)
Best Trailer: DH
Worst overall Movie: CoS
Best Visuals: HBP
Best Special Effects: HBP
Best Quidditch Game: I can't decide, anyone's opinion?

thisishogwarts

Quidditch is HBP or Poa for me. I just found the first 2 Quidditch games cheesy. I loved when Ginny scores and takes out two players at the same time. And Ron as Keeper: so funny.

Richard

Quidditch is POA definitely aaron,hbp was too short......i like how the dementors come and when hermione screams go harry...whoo hooo....go harry!!!
R:,)

thisishogwarts

Oh and best Dumbledore: HBP. I don't care what people think of Gambon, he was perfect in HBP and PoA. But I'm giving the edge to HBP because he was absolutely brilliant during the Astronomy Tower scene. I couldn't see Harris doing that scene. I liked him in SS and CoS, but he wouldn't fit into the later films. Now only if Gambon was great in GoF, he would be hands down the best DD.

jonny7003

Best movie overall: POA
Best Music: Nicholas Hooper for HBP
Best Directing: Alfonso Cuaron for PoA
Best Editing: PoA
Best Cinematography: HBP
Best Story: POA
Best Acting (younger cast): Daniel Radcliffe in Order of the Phoenix
Best Acting (adult cast): Jim Broadbent in Half-Blood Prince
Best Comedy: HBP
Best Pacing: POA
Best Song from entire series: Fawkes the Phoenix in COS (There's so many but I LOVE this one)
Best Opening: HBP
Best Ending: HBP
Best Set Design: All
Best Harry: POA
Best Ron: GoF
Best Hermione: POA
Best Ending Credits: GoF
Most Epic Moment: The Cave in HBP
Best Hair Style: PoA
Darkest Movie: OOTP
Best Trailer: DH
Worst overall Movie: I don't know
Best Visuals: HBP
Best Special Effects: GOF
Best Quidditch Game: POA
Dumbledore: HBP

Richard

Best music is john williams for poa,hooper is second....also best track is window to the past,second fawkes the phoenix.......
R:,)

thisishogwarts

Idk why people didn't like Hooper's score to HBP. To me, SS and CoS sounded EXACTLY the same besides Fawkes the Pheonix. That track was great. PoA was a huge step up. GoF: ehh...it was OK. Tried to be WAY TO EPIC. OoTP was good, nothing amazing. And HBP is my 2nd favorite soundtrack. So powerful and sad.

jonny7003

IMO, HBP was the most emotional and very magical too.

aaron

Mine:

Best movie overall: HBP
Best Music: John Williams for POA
Best Directing: Alfonso Cuaron for POA
Best Editing: POA
Best Cinematography: HBP
Best Story: HBP
Best Acting (younger cast): Emma Watson in HBP
Best Acting (adult cast): Jim Broadbent in Half-Blood Prince
Best Comedy: HBP
Best Pacing: POA
Best Song from entire series: A Window to the Past from POA
Best Opening: HBP
Best Ending: HBP
Best Set Design: OOTP
Best Harry: HBP
Best Ron: HBP
Best Hermione: HBP
Best Ending Credits: POA
Most Epic Moment: Journey to the Cave, HBP
Best Hair Style: POA
Darkest Movie: GOF
Best Trailer: DH
Worst overall Movie: COS
Best Visuals: HBP
Best Special Effects: HBP
Best Quidditch Game: HBP
Dumbledore: HBP

thisishogwarts

I agree with it being the most emotional. DD's Farewell was so amazing. So was In Noctem, Opening, Slughorn's Confession, and Into the Rushes. I loved every single track, even School!. I just thought PoA was more magical.

UniversHarryPotter.c

http://chud.com/articles/articles/24631/1/COMIC-CON-HARRY-POTTER-AND-THE-OSCAR-STATUE/Page1.html

jonny7003

I love POA's score because it had that medieval theme to it, but HBP just about tops it for me. POA's still an incredibly close second and some tracks from Doyle's GOF were lovely like Harry in Winter etc..

aaron

@UniversHarryPotter that article was amazing.

thisishogwarts

I loved The Story Continues, Harry in Winter, and Cedric's Death from GoF. Other then that, it was eh.

jonny7003

@thisishogwarts Yeah that was about it for me too lol

@Universharrypotter Thanks for the article

UniversHarryPotter.c

yes aaron it was

thisishogwarts

Lol someone was like "Were you high? 6 was by far the worst"

Did he see CoS?

thisishogwarts

I don't agree it needs a Best Picture nom., but it does need a Oscar win in SOME category. Like Cinematography for Eduardo Sierra or Music for Desplat, or most likely: Set Design for Stuart Craig.

Richard

Best movie:POA
Best music:John williams for POA
Best directing:Alfonso cuaron
Best Quidditch:POA
Best death:Dumbledore in HBP
Darkest movie:GOF
Comedy:GOF
Best story:GOF
Best trailer DH
Most kiddie:COS
Worst overall:COS
Best hermione:POA
Best Ron:OOTP
Best Harry:HBP
Best Opening:POA
Best song ever:Window to the past
Best couple:Ron and hermione
Best action:Fight in the ministry
Best task in GOF:The maze
Best end credits:POA
Best trailer:Deathly Hallows
Best adult actor:Alan rickman
Best wand:Dumbledores
Most epic scene:The cave travel
Most emotional scene:Dumbledores death
Most hated character:Umbridge
And there u go.....
R:,)

jonny7003

Stuart Craig definately needs a win. He's superb.

thisishogwarts

@jonny: I 100% agree. Why he didn't win for GoF is beyond me.

And I have a feeling DH 1 is gonna get a ton of noms. From Cinematography to Set Design to all the tech stuff and MAYBE score by Desplat.

Richard

I HOPE IT GETS BEST PICTURE!!!!!!!!
R

jonny7003

I hope Desplat gets a nomination. I know he'll be brilliant.

Richard

yeah......i hope he does too.
R

flaviobessajr

My opinion:

Best movie: OotP
Best music: John williams for POA (though I LOVE Nicholas Hooper songs)
Best directing: David Yates
Best Quidditch: I dunno. We just watched complete games in the first two. But quidditch get better in PoA and HBP.
Best death: Dumbledore in HBP
Darkest movie: HBP
Comedy: HBP (:/)
Best story: OotP
Most kiddie: PS
Worst overall: CoS!!!
Best Hermione: POA
Best Ron: OOTP
Best Harry: PS
Best Opening: HBP
Best song ever: SUCH DIFFICULT THING! Err... There's a lot but, Leaving Hogwarts is pretty amazing.
Best couple: Ron and hermione
Best action: Fight in the ministry
Best task in GOF: The First Task
Best end credits: POA
Best trailer: Deathly Hallows!!!
Best adult actor: Alan rickman
Best wand: Dumbledore's
Most epic scene: Journey to the cave (and the cave!)
Most emotional scene: Harry talking with Sirius at Grimmauld's Place about Harry's turning a bad person
Most hated character: Umbridge

dashape80

Best movie overall: HBP or PoA
Best Music: John Williams for PoA
Best Directing: Alfonso Cuaron for PoA
Best Editing: PoA
Best Cinematography: HBP
Best Story: PoA
Best Acting (younger cast): Daniel Radcliffe in Half Blood Prince
Best Acting (adult cast): Jim Broadbent for HBP
Best Comedy: COS
Best Pacing: GOF
Best Song from entire series: Window to the Past, PoA
Best Opening: OOTP
Best Ending: HBP
Best Set Design: OOTP
Best Harry: HBP
Best Ron: GoF
Best Hermione: HBP or CoS
Best Ending Credits: GoF
Most Epic Moment: The Graveyard in GOF
Darkest Movie: OoTP
Best Trailer: DH
Worst overall Movie: SS
Best Visuals: HBP
Best Special Effects: HBP
Best Quidditch Game: HBP

thisishogwarts

Ok:

Wost acting: Bonnie Wright in HBP
Worst HP movie: CoS- I still like it, but its by far the weakest.
Worst line: "Their's no Hogwarts without you Hagrid" -UGH! WTF! And evidently Kloves never wanted that line in the movie, but Columbus forced him to put it in the script.

dashape80

LOL

Worst acting: All the kids in SS LOL
Worst HP Movie: SS
Worst Line: "He was there friend" PoA

Braveheart

Best movie overall: POA
Best Music: John Williams for PoA
Best Directing: Alfonso Cuaron for PoA
Best Editing: PoA
Best Cinematography: HBP
Best Story: PoA
Best Acting (younger cast): Rupert Grint HBP (in all the films really)
Best Acting (adult cast): Jim Broadbent for HBP
Best Comedy: GOF
Best Pacing: POA
Best Song from entire series: Window to the Past, PoA
Best Opening: GOF
Best Ending: OOTP
Best Set Design: HBP
Best Harry: POA
Best Ron: OOTP
Best Hermione: HBP
Best Ending Credits: POA
Most Epic Moment: The Graveyard in GOF
Darkest Movie: OOTP
Best Trailer: DH
Worst overall Movie: COS
Best Visuals: HBP
Best Special Effects: GOF
Best Quidditch Game: POA
Worst Acting: Bonnie Wright HBP, followed closely by Emma Watson GOF
Worst Ending: HBP
Worst Opening: COS
Worst Lighting: OOTP
Best Lighting: HBP

aaron

Cheesiest Moment: Hermione and Hagrid's return at the end of COS. Simply unbearable.

thisishogwarts

I agree with that 100% aaron.

I don't know why people hate "HE WAS THEIR FRIEND!" moment in PoA. I didn't see it as horribly as everyone else does.

But another bad moment was "I love magic" in GoF. Like really, Kloves?

Richard

Haha...i liked the ending of cos wen i was a kid,now its cheesy,but still i like it its not bad at all,i like the music without it it would be stupid......the music is like an important second actor in a film....
R:,)

aaron

I just feel like everybody is treating COS really bad, even me. We just can't emphasize enough that its not a BAD FILM, just the weakest of the bunch. Plus the critics seem to think COS was the third worst behind SS and OOTP.

Richard

yeah.....COS WE ALL LOVE U!!!!!!!!!!
R

thisishogwarts

I think once we see (and by once, I mean IF) we see OoTP with the 50+ minutes put back into the film, we can judge it differently. Case in point: Kingdom of Heaven back in 2005 was eh and forgettable. With the director's cut that came out, I can easily say its one of my favorites films. Its like a different film all together. Another point why Ridley Scott films need to be uncut in order to be amazing.

Richard

i dont think well ever see the 3 hour ootp:(
R

GodricGryffindor

Okay, so here's mine :

Best movie overall: HBP or PoA
Best Music: John Williams SS or PoA OR Nicholas Hooper for HBP
Best Directing: Alfonso Cuaron for PoA or David Yates for HBP
Best Editing: PoA
Best Cinematography: HBP
Best Story: SS
Best Acting (younger cast): Evanna Lynch for OOTP , Tom Felton for HBP , Emma Watson for HBP
Best Acting (adult cast): Miranda Richardson for GOF, Michael Gambon for HBP, Jim Broadbent for HBP, Imelda Staunton for OOTP
Best Comedy: HBP
Best Pacing: GOF
Best Song: Window to the Past, PoA
Best Opening: HBP
Best Ending: POA (I don't know it was so different)
Best Set Design: OOTP
Best Harry: SS, POA, HBP
Best Ron: OOTP or HBP
Best Hermione: HBP or POA
Best Ending Credits: POA
Most Epic Moment: The whole CAVE sequence in HBP
Darkest Movie: OOTP
Best Trailer: DH
Best Visuals: HBP or GOF
Best Special Effects: HBP
Best Quidditch Game: HBP
Best couple: Ron & Hermione
Best action: Ministry sequence in OOTP
Best Magical Creature: Hungarian Horntail
Best task in GOF: The first Task
Best wand: ALL OF THEM!
Most emotional scene: Tribute to Dumbledore in HBP (Seeing that tear fall from Emma Watson's face was perfect.)
Most hated character: Cornelius Fudge (IMO)
Best Dumbledore : HBP

Worst film overall: I don't have this category because all of them have pros and cons love them all
Worst acting (young): Leanne (Katie's friend) for HBP
Worst Acting (adult): NONE
Worst Line: "I love magic" - Harry GOF
Worst Opening & Worst Closing: NONE! I feel like each of these represent something different for each film and upcoming.

Best/Memorable quote: Now, if you two don't mind, I'm going to bed
before either of you come up with another
clever idea to get us killed, or worse, expelled.

- Hermione Granger


Pretty much that's it

Godric Gryffindor

Richard

Haha godric,nice list man^^
R:,)

GodricGryffindor

Thanks!

G.G.

Richard

love your categories.....
R:,)

GodricGryffindor

Haha thanks!
My favorite category was the QUOTE one lol

G.G.

Richard

Yeah its mine too hahaha,thats my fave quote as well love hermione /emma lol
R:,)

Braveheart

You sure you don't just love Hermione BECAUSE of Emma? :D Lol.

Richard

Hahaha good one brave heart^^ im sure i love her caracter in the books,i love smart girls^^ and emma is smart too so.....
R:,)

GodricGryffindor

^100% AGREED!

G.G.

Richard

Thanks^^ well i gotta go godric talk later^^
R:,)

aaron

Update, lets bring these to the top.

Nick

ok

UniversHarryPotter.c

Best movie overall: HBP
Best Music: John Williams and Nicholas Hooper
Best Directing: Yates for HBP
Best Editing: HBP
Best Cinematography: HBP
Best Story: exaequo PoA and HBP
Best Acting (younger cast): Daniel Radcliffe in Half Blood Prince
Best Acting (adult cast): Alan Rickman
Best Comedy: GoF
Best Pacing: HBP
Best Song from entire series: Window to the Past, Dumbledore Farewell
Best Opening: HBP
Best Ending: HBP
Best Set Design: All the movies
Best Harry: HBP
Best Ron: HBP
Best Hermione: HBP
Best Ending Credits: CoS with the Lockhart add ^^
Most Epic Moment: The Journey to the cave in HBP
Best Hair Style: HBP
Darkest Movie: HBP
Best Trailer: DH
Worst overall Movie: GoF
Best Visuals: HBP
Best Special Effects: HBP
Best Quidditch Game: HBP
Best kisses scenes : Lavande Ron for the moment in HBP (hope Ron/Hermione will be the best after all )
Worst play emotional moment : "he was their friend" PoA