Home General
Welcome to Harry Potter Forum! Below you will find many interesting threads and discussions. Enjoy.

POA or HBP films different from the book...

RichardRichard Posts: 48,703 mod
edited June 2010 in General
So wich of these films is more different from the book? I say HBP. Dashape saysPOA. He even says that GOF and OOTP are more different from the book than HBP is. Now I have proof that HBP is more different: No scrimgeour or "the other minister",spinners end scene is not in the right order,No dursleys,Cafe scene added,Luna saves HP not Tonks,No apparation scenes,no dobby,kreacher,bill,and fleur. Memories are way reduced. Not much horcrux talk,no BATTLE at the end,HP is not under invisible cloak wen DD gets killed,Greybacks character reduced,and NO funeral. Not even the HP and Ginny break up. Now dashape,I'd like u to give out your reasonings.(Now dashape,I don't want there to be a rivalry between us,I'm just trying to back up wat I said ok?!?)
R:,))))))
«1

Comments

Sign In or Register to comment.